Before You Remove That Tree: What Massachusetts Homeowners Should Know About Insurance Tree Notices
If your insurance company sends a letter telling you to prune or remove a tree, do not assume removal is your only option.
As arborists, we believe safety comes first. Trees should be evaluated honestly, and some trees do need to come down. But tree risk cannot be judged well from a satellite image alone. A meaningful assessment requires an on-site look at the tree’ s health, structure, species, surroundings, and potential targets.
The concern many in our industry share is that broad insurance directives, especially those based only on aerial images, can lead to unnecessary removals or improper pruning. In some cases, rushed or poorly planned tree work may actually make a tree less safe over time.
For Massachusetts homeowners, this issue has become increasingly relevant. Legislation has been filed on Beacon Hill addressing the concern that home insurers may pressure property owners to remove trees without proper professional review. The larger point is simple: homeowners should not feel forced into removing a healthy or manageable tree without a qualified, inperson evaluation.
A well-maintained tree is often far safer than a neglected one. In many cases, the right solution is not removal, but thoughtful pruning, deadwood removal, monitoring, cabling, soil care, or another targeted risk-reduction measure recommended by a qualified arborist.
This is also why credentials matter. A certified arborist has training in tree biology, diagnosis, pruning, and safety. Some arborists also hold additional tree risk assessment qualifications, which provide a standardized process for evaluating risk. These credentials help homeowners identify professionals who understand not only how to remove trees, but how to assess and care for them.
The wrong pruning can do real damage. Indiscriminate cutting, topping, or excessive canopy reduction can weaken structure, stimulate weak regrowth, and shorten the life of a tree. Not all“ tree work” improves safety. Good tree work is thoughtful, selective, and based on the needs of the tree and the site.
Some trees do need to be removed. But that decision should be made carefully,
WE’ RE FEELING SOCIAL!
professionally, and for the right reasons.
Before you remove a tree, get a qualified arborist’ s opinion.
What to do if you receive an insurance tree notice
Don’ t panic. A notice is not the same as a professional tree diagnosis.
• Ask for specifics.
• Request the insurer’ s concern in writing.
• Call a qualified arborist.
• An in-person evaluation matters.
• Ask about options.
• Pruning, monitoring, cabling, soil care, or other mitigation may be possible.
• Avoid rushed decisions.
• Tree removal should be based on sound information, not fear.
We love sharing what we are learning, noticing, planting, preserving, and protecting. Follow along for seasonal tree care updates, project stories, plant health information, and glimpses into the daily work of arboriculture.
Harrison McPhee, Inc Harrison _ McPhee _ Inc and # NextGenArborist Harrison McPhee, Inc