Australian Doctor Australian Doctor 12 May 2017 | Page 3
Dipsticks don’t work in
uncomplicated UTI: study
JOCELYN WRIGHT
GPs could do away with tests for
symptomatic uncomplicated UTIs
and treat empirically with antibi-
otics, a study suggests.
Primary care researchers from
Belgium have shown that most
women who have negative bacte-
rial tests after presenting with clas-
sical UTI symptoms show signs of
infection when retested with the
gold-standard PCR testing.
In their study of 220 sympto-
matic women, traditional MSU
culture tests found UTI pathogens
in 81% of samples.
However, 90% of women with
negative results tested positive for
Escherichia coli on PCR testing.
This may have been due to
the presence of low counts of E.
Coli below the usual threshold or
because the pathogen persisted as
an intracellular ‘biofilm’, causing
inflammation and symptoms, the
researchers said.
Their findings supported the
idea that routine testing may be
unnecessary for women with
symptoms of an uncomplicated
UTI, who could be treated empiri-
cally with antibiotics, they said.
“Instead of spending time and
energy to prove an uncomplicated
THE boss of corporate giant IPN has
quit to become the new CEO of the
company’s biggest rival, Primary
Health Care.
The shock move by Dr Malcolm
Parmenter — the face of IPN for over
a decade — was announced last
week.
He will be paid $1.65 million a year,
with up to a million dollars more on
offer in performance bonuses.
Primary has been in the market for
a new CEO since current boss Peter
Gregg announced he would step
down after being charged with the
falsification of company documents
during his stint at construction giant
Leighton Holdings.
Primary has attempted to rebrand
itself following the death of founder
Dr Ed Bateman in 2015 but has
had a hard time attracting sufficient
numbers of GPs.
Dr Parmenter joined IPN in 2000
Traditional urine cultures
would still have a role, if
treatment failed or if there
was evidence of a more
complicated UTI.
UTI, physicians can rely on the
typical symptoms and focus on
acknowledging and managing the
patient’s complaints,” the Univer-
sity of Ghent researchers advised.
However, traditional urine cul-
tures would still have a role to
play, if treatment failed or if there
was evidence of a more compli-
cated UTI, they conceded.
Melbourne GP Dr Sara Whit-
burn said the findings confirmed
what often happened in practice
and would give GPs greater confi-
dence to treat empirically.
“It does mean we have to be
quite clear about what symptoms
the women are feeling because we
have to be confident we’re getting
a good history of an uncompli-
cated UTI,” she told Australian
Doctor.
“A good symptom history is
as useful as doing dipstick and
investigations, and I think [these
findings] will be really useful in
practice,” she added.
As a GP specialising in women’s
health, Dr Whitburn said she saw
many women experiencing other
vaginal symptoms and advised
“anything that doesn’t fit an
uncomplicated UTI” still merits an
MSU.
Clinical Microbiology and Infection
2017; online.
while working as a GP at the Mosman
Practice on Sydney’s North Shore,
now one of IPN’s largest privately
billing practices.
He rose rapidly and was appointed
CEO in 2006. He went on to achieve
annual revenues of nearly $400
million.
As CEO, Dr Parmenter acheived revenues of nearly $400 million for IPN.
He will take up his position as
Primary’s managing director and CEO
in September. Mr Gregg will continue
to run the $1.75 billion healthcare
group in the meantime.
Primary’s chairman, Rob Ferguson,
says Dr Parmenter is “ideally placed
to lead the company through the next
stage of its evolution”.
Primary’s profits have declined
sharply in recent years, partly
because of pressure on its bulk-billing
medical centres amid the Medicare
freeze.
The company expects a full-year
after-tax underlying profit of around
$92 million for 2017, down from $104
million in 2016 and $111.5 million in
2015.
As a sign of the times, it has
recently shifted away from a reliance
on universal bulk-billing, partnering
with former AMA president Dr Kerryn
Phelps to launch a private billing
venture, Health & Co.
Opioid scripts land doctor couple with $30k fine
ANTONY SCHOLEFIELD
A HUSBAND and wife, both doctors,
have both been found guilty of
professional misconduct after
one inappropriately prescribed
oxycodone to the other.
Adelaide anaesthetist Dr Christie
Lang was accused of unlawfully
prescribing oxycodone to her
husband for more than two months
without authority.
In the same proceedings, brought
by the Medical Board of Australia,
Staff wri ters
Restraints still used on
mental health patients
IPN boss jumps ship to biggest rival
BRETT EVANS
In Brief
plastic surgeon Dr Clayton Lang was
accused of inappropriately procuring
the drug from his wife.
The board claimed that both
doctors had also prescribed
oxycodone to a family friend for
more than two months, without
authority and without taking
adequate notes.
The couple admitted all the
accusations.
The SA Health Practitioners
Tribunal said both doctors were
extremely competent in their own
fields.
“Both are contrite and have learnt
their lesson. The lapses giving rise
to these proceedings will not be
repeated,” the tribunal said.
“[Dr Christie Lang’s] CV and
references leave no doubt that she
is a hard-working and extremely
competent anaesthetist who holds
high moral and ethical values for
which she is highly respected by her
peers.
www.australiandoctor.com.au
“[Dr Clayton Lang’s] CV and
references indicate that he is
extremely competent in his specialty
and is highly regarded by his
peers, all of whom are aware of his
difficulties with the board in this
matter.”
The tribunal fined them $15,000
each but decided not to suspend
either of them.
They were also ordered to pay
$12,500 to cover the medical
board’s legal costs.
MENTAL health patients are
still being physically and
mechanically restrained despite
a push to eliminate the practice
in Australia. National data on
restraints in specialised public
mental health hospitals, released
last week, show the rate of
people physically restrained in
2015-16 was about nine times for
every 1000 bed-days. Mechanical
restraint involving the use of
either straps and belts was less
common, at under two events
per 1000 bed days. Children
were physically restrained at a
rate of 11 times per 1000 days
in a mental health bed. Rates of
physical restraint were highest for
forensic services, at about 110
events per 1000 beds-days — 20
times the rate for general mental
health services.
AIHW report: Mental Health
Services in Australia:
bit.ly/1MC78OI
Hold the phone, waiting
room music fees set to rise
THE sounds of Barry White
wafting through the waiting
room will become a little more
expensive from July. Fees for
playing licensed music in waiting
rooms or during phone calls are
set to rise by 1.5%. Payable to
the Phonographic Performance
Company of Australia, the tariffs
apply to practices playing music
from any source other than TV
and radio, which are exempt
from licensing requirements.
Surgeries with between three and
five external phone lines must
pay $156 for hold music, while
the fee for waiting room music
is just under $78. To receive a
hard copy of the new tariffs, email
PPCA at [email protected] or
call (02) 8569 1123.
Australia’s first medical
cannabis shipment arrives
THE first two commercial
shipments of medicinal cannabis
products have arrived in Australia
under the Federal Government’s
new policy to allow controlled
importation of the drug. The
shipments to Melbourne and
Perth, both from Canada, are
expected to be followed by
others throughout the month.
Federal Minister for Health Greg
Hunt said children suffering
from epilepsy and patients
dealing with side effects caused
by cancer treatment were
most likely to benefit from the
products.
12 May 2017 | Australian Doctor |
3