CLINICAL NEWS
Complete Mutation Clearance Predicts Longer Survival and Lower Relapse Risk in AML
Somatic mutation clearance ( MC ) at complete remission ( CR ) of acute myeloid leukemia ( AML ) was associated with improved survival and reduced risk of relapse , according to results of a study published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology . Specifically , somatic MC in the nonpreleukemic genes was associated with reduced relapse risk and longer survival .
These data suggest that , as a whole , the persistence of these mutations “ may function as a molecular minimal residual disease ( MRD ) marker in AML ,” Koichi Takahashi , MD , from The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston , and coauthors noted .
To test this hypothesis , researchers performed DNA sequencing on samples collected from 131 patients with untreated AML who were studied in three phase II trials . Patients had received frontline intensive induction chemotherapy consisting of idarubicin plus cytarabine and achieved morphologic CR at 30 days following therapy .
“ [ Mutation clearance ] may be a promising tool with which to identify patients with AML who are at high risk of relapse .”
— KOICHI TAKAHASHI , MD
Investigators characterized three levels of MC ( based on variant allele frequency [ VAF ] of residual mutations at CR ):
• MC2.5 , meaning at least one mutation persisted with a VAF < 2.5 %
• MC1.0 , meaning at least one mutation persisted with a VAF < 1 %
• complete MC ( CMC ), meaning no persistent mutations
The authors also assessed event-free survival ( EFS ), overall survival ( OS ), and cumulative incidence of relapse ( CIR ) from the data of CR .
The median VAF of pre-treatment mutations was 0.30 ( range = 0.17-0.42 ), and the most frequently mutated genes in the cohort included :
• NPM1 ( 28 %; n = 37 )
• DNMT3A ( 24 %; n = 32 )
• FLT3 ( 22 %; n = 29 ), 62 % as internal tandem duplication and 38 % as non-internal tandem duplication
• CEBPA ( 15 %; n = 20 )
MC2.5 , MC1.0 , and CMC was achieved in 75 ( 57 %), 64 ( 49 %), and 59 patients ( 45 %), respectively . “ Rates of MC varied by the mutated genes ,” the authors reported . “ We observed frequent persistence of somatic mutations at CR in genes that are often preleukemic ( e . g ., DNMT3A , TET2 , SRSF2 , ASXL1 , and TP53 ), whereas mutations in NPM1 , hematopoietic transcription factors , or the receptor tyrosine kinase pathway were often cleared ” ( see
TABLE ).
The rates also differed by molecular pathway : Mutations in hematopoietic transcription factors or receptor tyrosine kinase genes had higher MC rates ; mutations associated with clonal hematopoiesis of indeterminate potential , DNA methylation , and RNA splicing had lower MC rates .
Patients who achieved CMC had lower median pre-treatment VAF than those who did not ( 0.41 [ range = 0.31-0.47 ] vs . 0.25 [ range = 0.14-0.36 ]; p < 0.001 ).
During a median follow-up of 35.2 months ( range = 28.3-39.7 months ), approximately 39 percent of patients ( n = 51 ) experienced relapse and 37 percent ( n = 49 ) died . Participants who achieved MC1.0 and CMC had significantly improved two-year OS and significantly lower CIR :
• 2-year OS : 75 % vs . 61 % ( MC1.0 vs . non- MC1.0 ; p = 0.05 ) and 77 % vs . 60 % ( CMC vs . non-CMC ; p = 0.03 )
• 2-year CIR : 26 % vs . 46 % ( MC1.0 vs . non- MC1.0 ; p = 0.03 ) and 24 % vs . 46 % ( CMC vs . non-CMC ; p = 0.03 )
However , in participants achieving MC2.5 versus not achieving MC2.5 or better , no significant differences were found for any of the study outcomes .
These associations remained constant in multivariable analyses that adjusted for age , cytogenetic risk , allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation ( alloHCT ), and flow cytometry – based MRD status : Patients who achieved CMC at remission had greater EFS ( hazard ratio [ HR ] = 0.43 ; p < 0.01 ), OS ( HR = 0.47 ; p = 0.04 ), and CIR ( HR = 0.27 ; p < 0.001 ) than those who did not achieve CMC .
“ The real impact of MRD assessment will be observed when it affects clinical decision making ,” the researchers explained .
The relatively small sample size limited the investigators ’ ability to characterize the MC rate of individual mutations . In addition , considering that most patients in the analysis were younger than 60 years , these findings may not be generalizable to older patients , nor to other centers where assessments of mutation status differ .
“ MC may be a promising tool with which to identify patients with AML who are at high risk of relapse ,” the authors concluded , “ and should be explored , along with [ flow cytometry – detected ] MRD , as an MRD marker in AML .”
The corresponding authors report no financial conflicts .
REFERENCE
Morita K , Kantarjian HM , Wang F , et al . Clearance of somatic mutations at remission and the risk of relapse in acute myeloid leukemia . J Clin Oncol . 2018 Apr 27 . [ Epub ahead of print ]
TABLE . Rate of Mutation Clearance on the Basis of Genes and Molecular Pathways
Gene or Pathway |
Mutation Clearance |
|
MC2.5 |
p Value |
MC1.0 |
p Value |
CMC |
p Value |
DNMT3A |
29.4 % ( 10 / 34 ) |
< 0.001 |
26.5 % ( 9 / 34 ) |
< 0.001 |
20.6 % ( 7 / 34 ) |
< 0.001 |
TET2 |
57.9 % ( 11 / 19 ) |
< 0.001 |
52.6 % ( 10 / 19 ) |
0.001 |
52.6 % ( 10 / 19 ) |
0.001 |
SRSF2 |
14.3 % ( 1 / 7 ) |
< 0.001 |
14.3 % ( 1 / 7 ) |
< 0.001 |
14.3 % ( 1 / 7 ) |
< 0.001 |
ASXL1 |
55.6 % ( 5 / 9 ) |
0.004 |
44.4 % ( 4 / 9 ) |
0.002 |
44.4 % ( 4 / 9 ) |
0.002 |
TP53 |
44.4 % ( 4 / 9 ) |
0.001 |
22.2 % ( 2 / 9 ) |
< 0.001 |
22.2 % ( 2 / 9 ) |
< 0.001 |
NPM1 |
100 % ( 37 / 37 ) |
0.493 |
97.3 % ( 36 / 37 ) |
0.615 |
97.3 % ( 36 / 37 ) |
0.615 |
Tyrosine kinase pathway |
92.7 % ( 76 / 82 ) |
N / A |
89.0 % ( 73 / 82 ) |
N / A |
87.8 % ( 72 / 82 ) |
N / A |
Transcription factor pathway |
91.9 % ( 91 / 99 ) |
0.99 |
87.9 % ( 87 / 99 ) |
0.99 |
85.9 % ( 85 / 99 ) |
0.827 |
MC = mutation clearance ; CMC = complete mutation clearance ; N / A = not available |
ASHClinicalNews . org ASH Clinical News
17