anti-austerity movement in spain Anti-Austerity-Movement-in-Spain | Page 10
10
5.1
5
Citizens’ Security law
The Anti-austerity movement in Spain is fundamentally
rooted in the gathering of the nations’ citizens in the
street to voice resistance to Spain’s unopposed right wing
government dominated by the People’s Party. However,
the recently passed Citizens Security Law (dubbed the
“gag law”), viewed by many as a blatant restriction of
civil liberties comparable to the dictatorship of Francisco
Franco, is designed to quell this opposition in order to
maintain the hold it has on Spanish society. In response,
the Spanish people subverted these measures by protest-
ing via holograms instead, avoiding arrest and setting an
incredibly unique precedent across the world.
5.1.1
Background: Protests
On May 15, 2011, powerful, relentless chants of “sí, se
puede” (roughly “yes, it can be done”) could be heard
echoing from the thousands of young Spaniards known as
los indignados (“the indignants”) filling Madrid’s Puerta
Del Sol Square as well as 57 other Spanish cities. This
is how the Spanish Anti-Austerity Movement began: “an
impromptu revolt of thousands…rallying against a polit-
ical establishment felt to be out of sync with the people”
which continued for many days yet. [127] Four years later,
on January 31, 2015, the same cries of “si, se puede” rang
through the same square in central Madrid, this time in
the form of Podemos (“we can”), an insurgent force with
roots in los indignados’ ideology and vision for Spain. [128]
Podemos’ fundamentally anti-corruption platform, the in-
credibly high standards of purity, and its singularity in
“threatening to bring an end to the bipartisan political
system that has governed Spain since the death of gen-
eral Francisco Franco in 1975” brought Podemos eas-
ily to the top of opinion polls last year in anticipation
of “a year packed with municipal, regional, and general
elections.” [128] The new party’s moralistic overtones com-
bined with its impeccable timing and lack of similar com-
petition struck a chord with the nation’s youth among
many others and won it 1.2 million votes and five seats
in May’s European elections.
5.1.2
Content
Podemos is an example of a strong resurgence from the
left across Europe to crippling austerity measures in sev-
eral countries that have left citizens homeless, jobless,
and without hope. [129][130] In Spain, nearly 25% of peo-
ple are unemployed and evictions have reached a rate of
as high as 500 per day among a wide variety of other
economic issues, leading to a number of generally peace-
ful protests seeking change in the way the government
handles them. [131] In addition to forming the founda-
tion of Podemos as well as Ciudadanos, another fun-
damentally anti-austerity and anti-corruption party, [132]
these protests have elicited multiple attempts by the gov-
2014 EVENTS
ernment to silence them culminating in what many see
as “something out of the generalissimo’s handbook”. [133]
The measures the law takes to silence the voices of
the Spanish people are absolutely devastating, including
unimaginably steep fines or jail time for disrespecting
police officers (600 euros), [134] taking and sharing im-
ages of state security forces that might endanger them or
their operations” (30,000 euros), [134] protesting in front
of government buildings, protesting at a time or loca-
tion not approved by the police (600,000 euros), [135] or
even using a hashtag in a tweet publicizing an event that
breaks the rules in any way. [136] Internet activity alone
can result in up to five years behind bars. [137] The law
also extends to even more restrictive and vague measures,
such as “playing games or sports in public spaces that are
not designed for such activity” (1000 euros), [138] “pro-
jecting ‘luminous devices’ (e.g. lasers) in the vicinity of
public transport in a way that ‘might cause accidents’”
(600,000 euros), [139] insulting the state or “participating
in the disruption of citizens’ security while using hoods,
helmets, or any other article of clothing or object that
covers the face, rendering identification difficult or im-
possible” (30,000 euros), [139] and “failure to cooperate
with law enforcement during crime investigations or in
the prevention of acts that might put citizens’ security at
risk” (30,000 euros). [139] Acts of terrorism under the act
include clauses as loosely defined as “the commission of
any serious crime against…liberty.” [139]
According to Spain’s interior minister, Jorge Fernández
Diaz, “It’s a law for the 21st Century. It provides bet-
ter guarantees for people’s security and more judicial se-
curity for people’s rights.” [140] What is allegedly an act
against terrorism “to guarantee a freer and more peaceful
coexistence for all Spaniards…eradicating violence,” [138]
ironically quite seriously threatens this ideal by making
police and federal security personnel (who are often re-
sponsible for committing this type of violence) signifi-
cantly less accountable, while expanding the role of pri-
vate security forces “lacking both proper training and the
proper level of public accountability” (assuming that nor-
mal police forces do indeed possess these qualities). [139]
Another problem with this policy is that it is fundamen-
tally anti-immigrant in nature, crippling the group tar-
geted most severely by austerity measures even more by
forcing everyone to present identity documents at inter-
net cafés, prohibitively complicating undocumented mi-
grants’ communications outside the country. [139] The law
also contains a provision validating and formalizing the
process of expulsion for Moroccans who jump the border
fence into Spain’s African outposts of Ceuta and Melilla,
which according to the International Federation for Hu-
man Rights “restrict[s] the right to seek asylum and vi-
olate[s] the principle of non-refoulement and the pro-
hibition of collective expulsions” as well as “[exposing]
migrants to a serious risk of torture and ill-treatment by
denying them the possibility of filing a claim against law
enforcement personnel in case of abuse.” [133]