African Mining May 2024 | Page 20

• EXCURSION

AN EXCURSION INTO THE NUANCES OF ALTERNATIVES

TO ALTERNATIVES IN ENERGY

The inherent high cost of some critical metals and elements has driven initiatives to search for alternatives , writes Dr Nicolaas C . Steenkamp , as he explores the nuances of an evolving critical mission in battery chemistry .
While promising , these alternatives often lag behind conventional lithium-ion batteries in energy density and cycle life , impacting driving range and battery lifespan . Additionally , some manganesebased materials exhibit voltage decay over time , requiring further research for optimisation .
Thomas Kelley | Unsplash

Lofty ambitions of largely replacing internal combustion engine vehicles with electric vehicles ( EVs ) by the end of the decade promises to rewrite the transportation landscape , however beneath the glossy veneer lies a hidden vulnerability – dependence on expensive and resource-limited metals like cobalt and lithium . The soaring costs and ethical concerns surrounding their extraction threaten to stall the EV revolution in its tracks . Recognising this precarious situation , the scientific community is embarking on a critical mission of adapting EV battery chemistry to reduce reliance on these problematic elements .

Prior to the collapse of the cobalt price early in 2023 , there was a call to embark on decoupling from cobalt . Cobalt ' s role in lithiumion batteries , the ubiquitous workhorse of EVs , is multifaceted . It enhances thermal stability , improves cycle life , and boosts energy density – all crucial for high-performance applications . However , its limited geological abundance and ethical concerns when it comes to mining practices , particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo , necessitate a shift away from its dominance . These concerns are however being addressed by initiatives like the Battery Passport .
Several strategies are emerging to combat cobalt dependence . Nickel-rich cathodes , containing less cobalt , are already seeing widespread adoption , albeit with trade-offs in stability and cost . Layered oxide cathodes incorporating manganese and vanadium hold promise for further cobalt reduction , offering improved affordability and environmental responsibility .
Lithium also experienced a dramatic drop in value in Q4 of 2023 . The dependency on lithium has its own set of challenges . Its scarcity and volatile price fluctuations raise concerns about long-term supply stability . Moreover , the environmental footprint of lithium extraction , particularly from brine pools , necessitates responsible sourcing practices .
Reducing lithium content without compromising energy density is a primary focus . Lithium iron phosphate ( LFP ) batteries , already popular in China , offer lower lithium requirements while boasting excellent safety and longevity , though their energy density falls short of some high-performance applications . Additionally , research into solid-state electrolytes , which would allow for the use of lithium metal anodes with significantly higher theoretical capacity , holds immense potential for further lithium decoupling .
Solid-state electrolyte technology is still in its infancy , facing challenges with scalability and manufacturing costs . Furthermore , lithium metal anodes pose fire risks that require robust safety measures to be addressed .
The introduction of a range of alternative battery chemistries are emerging as potential game-changers . Sodium-ion batteries , utilising abundant and inexpensive sodium resources , offer a costeffective option for stationary applications and grid storage . Redox flow batteries , with their inherent safety and modular design , excel in large-scale energy storage but their lower energy density limits their use in EVs .
Sodium-ion batteries show promise for budget-friendly EVs , particularly in regions with limited lithium resources . Research into advanced cathode materials is continuously improving their energy density and performance . Redox flow batteries offer a viable alternative for grid storage and renewable energy integration , contributing to decarbonisation efforts .
However , sodium-ion batteries currently lag behind lithiumion in energy density and charging speeds , requiring further breakthroughs for widespread EV adoption . Redox flow batteries '
18 • African Mining • May 2024 www . africanmining . co . za