OPERATIONS • in 2019 , the question is – perhaps it is time the DMRE sought to understand this sector more deeply ?
Regulation abuse , collusion and violence The first miner to share her journey was Mandy Malebe , CEO of Lethabo Exploration . Lethabo Exploration is 100 % South African owned ; 100 % black owned – and self-funded – presumably the epitome of the face of a transformed South African Mining industry that the DMRE is trying to achieve . However , Malebe said unequivocally , “ Being young and being a black woman doesn ' t change anything when it comes to regulatory challenges experienced daily by South African miners . Whether a company ticks the transformation box or not , it is not exempted from being plagued by the current ills of the industry . The challenges are standard and affect all .” The greatest abuse experienced by Lethabo Exploration was in fact accommodated by the DMRE . Perhaps , she noted , the DMRE on a national level is not aware of these abuses , however they are a reality at regional level .
“ We cannot shy away from speaking out about these things out of fear of what might happen . Because whether one speaks up or one keeps quiet , one suffers nonetheless !” She explained that there are certain DMRE officials at regional level aware of , if not allegedly involved in , collusion . “ Violence takes place and not always on the minesite . When investigations are conducted , it all boils down to someone feeling entitled or ‘ corruption insurance ’. These attacks are so brazen , it comes across as if the confidence of the perpetrators is fuelled by the backing or cover from an official at the Regulator .
“ We cannot have exploration companies or emerging miners being attacked because of minerals . Especially when these unsuspecting companies have financially invested in the prospecting – identifying and proving the minerals are there in the first place – and then when an official application is made to the DMRE for the mining right , suddenly an avalanche of additional applications appear out of nowhere . This is a common occurrence and even the majors have made complaints with regards this kind of activity ,” said Malebe .
Is the regulator regulating ? Access to information from the DMRE is one of the greatest challenges faced in the industry currently . It has been Lethabo ’ s experience that after submitting an application for a prospecting right , which was rejected by the DMRE ( without reasons supplied ), follow ups , queries and a subsequent objection as well as an internal appeal have remained unanswered for three years ; and this while the competing applicant had progressed and graduated to a mining right . The system simply does not work – delays result in redundancy of objections of those who are complying with the regulations . “ We were told by the regional manager at the DMRE that the RMDEC ( Regional Mining Development and Environmental Committee ) works separately to the procedures of the mining and
1 2
1 . Mandy Malebe , CEO of Lethabo Exploration – 100 % South African owned , 100 % black owned – and self-funded .
2 . Godfrey Mocwane , CEO at New Venture Mining Investment Holdings ( Pty ) Ltd , a veteran mining entrepreneur with decades of experience in the mining space , spoke of his disillusionment with the way things have panned out since the MPRDA was enacted in 2002 .
Prospecting Rights applications , as well as Objections and Internal Appeals .” The theory of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act of 2002 ( MPRDA ) does not work in practice and regulations are not consistently , equally or transparently applied by the Regulator ; and these loopholes are allegedly being exploited by those colluding within the system .
The repercussions are far reaching for all . What kind of investor invests in an unregulated environment , where the law is not upheld ? This is why Lethabo Exploration had to self-fund , which speaks to one of the greatest additional challenges juniors face . SLPs also then just become tick-boxes and not the far-reaching , meaningful and impactful programmes in the community they are devised to be . “ This is not a unique experience , operations such as Lethabo Exploration are held back financially with all the other struggles that we face , and we cannot live up to the promises in our SLPs ,” said Malebe .
Smart added that an additional and unintended consequence of these experiences is the adversarial relationship that has developed between the mining industry and the DMRE , who should in fact be championing the industry and whose constitutional obligation it is to see optimal exploitation of the nation ' s minerals .
Access to information from the DMRE is one of the greatest challenges faced in the industry currently .
www . africanmining . co . za African Mining Publication African Mining African Mining • June 2024 • 23