TECHNOLOGY •
Figure 3 : 10.97m ( 36 ’) diameter SAG mill with 18 % ball charge and 8 % rock charge @ 10.3rpm ( 80 % critical ).
Since the introduction of the top hat lifter concept , SAG mill diameters have grown as has the diameter of the steel balls added to the mills . The combination of larger balls being dropped from a greater height increased the amount of energy carried by the grinding ball which , when directed into the mill charge , increased the amount of impact breakage in the mill . However , if the ball struck the mill liners instead of the mill charge , this energy was then directed into the liners – with continued ball strikes leading to liner failure . Unplanned liner failure threatened milling budgets and , because the larger mills required more liners , which took more effort to replace ( they were heavier ), mill run times began to diminish , as did the mill operator ’ s confidence in the reliability of conventional steel liners . This , in turn , has been reflected by the current design assumption typically used for the design of AG-SAG mill circuits e . g ., 92 % run-time for the year as compared to an assumed 95 % run time used back in the mid-1990s , when mills were smaller . The disparity in mill run times will likely be exacerbated in the future with the introduction of 12.8m ( 42 ’) and 13.4m ( 44 ’) diameter mills .
8.8 7.5 6.3 5.0 4.4 3.8 3.2 2.5 1.9 1.3 0.7 0.1
VELOCITY the lifter starts to wear . The combination of insufficient lifter height and accelerated wear rates has the potential to adversely affect the efficiency and run time of AG-SAG mills greater than 12m ( 40 ’) diameter .
Over the last few years , the use of hybrid liners ( a composite of steel and rubber ) in large diameter SAG Mills , for example 34 ’ in diameter or larger , has increased in popularity due to the advantage of reduced liner weight . The reduction in weight means that the liner handler can now move larger liner pieces , which reduces the number of liners required to line the mill shell thereby reducing mill downtime . Tega Industries have recently reported that their liner design , which uses rolled steel inserts ( 400 – 550BHN ) 1 embedded in a polymer matrix , wore at a lower rate when compared to the all-steel liners ( 300 – 350BHN ), with the difference becoming an almost 30 % lower wear rate recorded over the last weeks of the liner ’ s service life . This allowed the Tega hybrid liner to operate with a steeper average face angle , which generated better charge lift that was reflected by a 1.5 % to 2 % increase in average mill power draw over the liner life , which contributed to the additional tonnes milled over the life of the liner set . The operators also reported that the Tega liner did not suffer from any premature failures or cracking , when compared to conventional steel liners .
Other operators reported that the Tega hybrid liners ’ ability to resist large and frequent impacts without cracking allowed them to operate the mill at full speed from day one of new hybrid liner installation , thereby eliminating the several week ramp-up period , which had been used for the previous approximately 20 years , to protect the traditional all-steel liner designs . The ability to operate the SAG mill at high speed immediately after the re-line resulted in SAG mill power draw increasing by approximately 3 % to 5 % over the life of the liners , thereby increasing the tonnes milled over the life of the liner set .
Images supplied by Mark Sherman
The damage caused by ball strikes on the Alumbrera SAG mill ’ s shell liner is depicted here – one can see the dimples on the surface of the liner caused by the steel ball strikes .
Whilst a 10 % increase in mill diameter does not sound significant , it produces a 21 % increase in mill cross-sectional area , which results in larger mill charge volumes . In order to maintain current milling efficiency , the larger mill charge volume will require taller lifter bars to capture the same amount of charge material for projection into motion . However , the challenge for steel liner suppliers will be to ensure that the metal properties are consistent throughout the casting . Current casting practice produces lifter bars that are softer in the centre of the casting , resulting in accelerated wear rates as
The other major advance recently reported in the industry was by Freeport McMoran Inc ( FMI ). The company presented the results of their fully automated mill re-lining system , developed in collaboration with Russell Mineral Equipment ( RME ), at September ’ s SAG 2023 Conference held in Vancouver , Canada . This relining system , which used robots combined with liners designed to be fastened from the outside ( i . e . ‘ through bolting ’ of the liners was not used ) produced a mill re-line that was completed without the
Over the last few years , the use of hybrid liners ( a composite of steel and rubber ) in large diameter SAG Mills , for example 34 ’ in diameter or larger , has increased in popularity due to the advantage of reduced liner weight . www . africanmining . co . za African Mining Publication African Mining African Mining • February 2024 • 17