African Mining April 2025 | Página 34

• FINANCE FORUM
returns, the panel explored the rise in more specialised financing instruments, including streaming, royalty financing, prepaids, project funding and sustainability funds.
What works and what doesn ' t?
The streaming debate Streaming involves a financing arrangement where a company provides upfront capital to a miner in exchange for a percentage of future production at a predetermined price. This model offers miners access to capital without diluting equity or increasing debt, but it does come with trade-offs. Once considered a last resort and priced accordingly, it has evolved significantly and is " now more sophisticated and complementary than it was in the past." However, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. " Streaming is not the right fit for every situation," noted Dendle.
The debate continued to expand on what constitutes a good or a bad stream. Successful streaming transactions typically focus on byproducts rather than core commodities, ensuring miners can secure upfront capital without significantly diluting their primary revenue stream. Streamers often provide capital before project financiers, assuming risk throughout the mine ' s lifecycle. Furthermore, good streams have a value-recognition angle. On the other hand, if a stream consumes too much cash flow, it can alter mine plans, sterilising the economics and disincentivising the mining operator, making for a suboptimal stream.
With the discussion revolving around the fact that mining is a highrisk sector, it was reiterated that it is critical to look at the timeline of the cycle, before adopting one or other financing instrument. Van Graan mentioned that a negative aspect of streaming is its long tenure, however the market for streams and the way they are used has changed. In addition, as a streamer you don ' t have to set volumes, so in a way, you are taking on some of the production risk. And as an operator, you are hedging against the product commodity price.
From a banker ' s perspective, Mofokeng noted that a stream doesn ' t count towards your indebtedness and its impact on EBITDA is small. He added, " A stream cleans up the balance sheet so from a bank ' s perspective it looks better."( Watch the video snippet of a bank ' s perspective on streaming)
Streaming is also a viable option when the capital stack needs diversification to manage risk effectively. As Dendle explained, " The ideal stream is a small slice of a big pie." The panel, however, cautioned against excessive reliance on streaming as it could overburden a project ' s cash flow and deter future lenders. In the ideal world, a mining company should balance streaming with other funding mechanisms to maintain financial flexibility. Mofokeng also commented towards the end of the discussion that streaming can be " flat for the life of the project or it can step up or down."
In response to a question from the audience regarding whether only certain commodities are suited to streaming, Dendle confirmed that products that require marketing or those that don ' t have a confirmed market price are very difficult to stream, such as diamonds, for example. Contract-based commodities are also tricky and there is not a great market for coal. Some base metals and lithium can be streamed but streaming is more suited to precious metals such as copper, gold, PGMs and others with a defined market value. He stressed, " You don ' t want to be on the wrong side of a commodity that is not your core business."( Watch the video clip of the suitability of commodities for streaming)
Alternative funding and future transactions Du Plessis queried the panel on the extent to which non-banking funding could affect one ' s ability, later in a project, to carry out mergers, acquisitions or other corporate transactions. While some financing structures impose limitations, streaming agreements often include buy-back options and flexible terms. Compared to traditional debt, streaming usually has fewer restrictive covenants. However, the complexity of alternative financing structures remains a challenge.
It was also mentioned that Export Credit Agency( ECA) finance is very complicated and typically policy driven. In South Africa, it is usually through state-owned entities and it also has dimensions for commercial banks. So, in general, ECAs, Development Finance Institutions and sustainability funding will be significantly more restrictive in terms of future transactions a miner may wish to engage in due to more stringent operating and compliance conditions imposed.
Tax considerations Du Plessis further questioned the panellists on whether there are any special tax considerations that people need to think about if they opt for one of the alternative funding mechanisms. The panel agreed that tax implications are relatively straightforward. " A prepaid is just an advance on future deliveries," explained De Landtsheer. " So, they will just pay corporate tax on physical deliveries."
Similarly, royalties are taxable upon receipt. In a zero-tax world, every stream would be a royalty but that is not the case. While some view a stream as a form of royalty with tax benefits, it remains a contractual agreement that avoids upfront tax burdens.( Watch the snippet of this discussion on our YouTube page)
32 • African Mining • April 2025 www. africanmining. co. za